Maple Shade, NJ might be modest in size, but when it comes to pizza, this community delivers big flavor. Whether you’re craving classic thin crust, hearty Sicilian, or artisanal wood-fired pies, Maple Shade has a pizza stop for every palate. Here are some of the most popular spots locals and visitors alike keep coming back to.
Local Classics and Fan Favorites
- Tacconelli’s Pizzeria. A long-time community staple, Tacconelli’s is beloved for its traditional pizza and generous toppings. With a strong reputation and consistently high reviews, it’s often one of the first places Maple Shade residents recommend for a classic slice or whole pie.
- Crust N Fire. Crust N Fire brings artisan flair to town and was even voted the best pizza in Maple Shade during a local pizza fest. Known for its perfectly charred crust and fresh, flavorful toppings, this spot also offers burgers and salads — making it a great choice for families or groups with varied tastes.
- Maple Shade Montegrillo Cucina Italiana. Maple Shade Montegrillo offers classic Italian pizzas with options ranging from plain cheese to fully loaded works. Locals appreciate its hearty pies and familiar neighborhood feel.
More Great Local Options
- Cafe Fontana. A favorite for both pizza and other Italian favorites, Cafe Fontana’s menu includes classic cheese, Sicilian, and specialty pizzas like buffalo chicken and white veggie. It’s a great choice if you want a sit-down meal with a slice or two.
- Sal & Joe’s Pizza & Restaurant. Sal & Joe’s serves up classic, no-frills pizza with a loyal following. Its crust and sauce are simple yet satisfying — a great stop for takeout night or casual dining.
- Sub Shoppe. While known primarily for sandwiches and wings, Sub Shoppe also offers a variety of pizza options that locals enjoy, especially for a quick and budget-friendly meal.
- Santi Pizza. Santi Pizza offers classic and casual pizza choices with a comfortable atmosphere — perfect for families and groups looking for an easy dinner out.
- Antonio’s Old World Pizza. Known for its specials and traditional pies, Antonio’s is another neighborhood favorite that consistently draws customers with its approachable menu and classic flavors.
Try Something New (or Old)
Whether you’re a fan of traditional Italian-style pizza, Sicilian squares, or creative specialty pies, Maple Shade’s pizza scene has something for everyone. From long-standing local institutions to newer artisan spots, each pizzeria adds its own flavor to the community’s culinary landscape.
If you’re new to the area — or thinking of making Maple Shade your home — exploring local favorites like these is a delicious way to get to know the town.
Looking for Homes in Maple Shade?
Love good pizza and great community living? Discover why Maple Shade is such an inviting place to live! Contact Brian Menchel for personalized help finding your next home in Maple Shade, or search available listings here to start exploring properties in this vibrant neighborhood.
